Less than 1,000 giant tortoises remained on Aldabra Atoll in the 19th century, following decades of human exploitation. Today, the island is home to approximately 183,000. It’s an extraordinary recovery. But the next chapter of this conservation success story could be considerably less encouraging for the island’s other inhabitants.
According to new research reported by The Guardian, Aldabra now supports the world’s largest free-roaming population of giant tortoises. The Seychelles island became a strict nature reserve in 1981 and a UNESCO World Heritage Site the following year. Where exploitation once threatened the tortoises with extinction, decades of protection have allowed their population to recover.
The latest estimate comes from 5 years of monitoring between 2018 and 2022. Although considerably higher than the previous estimate of 100,000 from the late 1990s, researchers found the population relatively stable during the study period. It’s an impressive demonstration of what protecting animals can achieve.
Unfortunately, not every animal on Aldabra enjoys the same protection.
Researchers identify feral cats and black rats as threats to tortoise eggs and hatchlings. Plans to eradicate these mammals are presented as a way to remove barriers to further population growth and improve the tortoises’ resilience to future environmental pressures. There’s a genuine problem here. Cats and rats prey on vulnerable tortoises, and protecting an animal from being eaten is hardly objectionable.
But conservation becomes ethically complicated when protecting one group of animals means eliminating another.
The cats and rats are described as invasive species, a classification that tells us something about their ecological impact but nothing about their individual interests. They are still sentient animals, regardless of whether conservationists want them there.
The Guardian’s report provides no details about how the proposed eradication would be conducted or whether non-lethal alternatives have been considered. Those questions deserve answers before removing thousands of potential predators is treated as the obvious next step.
Meanwhile, the tortoises face threats that cannot be addressed by removing other animals. Longer and more frequent droughts are expected to reduce available food and shade, while rising sea levels threaten low-lying areas of the atoll. Researchers rightly warn that the current population estimate represents a baseline rather than an endpoint. Protecting the tortoises will require continued monitoring and action.
But what constitutes successful conservation?
If success is measured exclusively through the population of a favoured species, the suffering or deaths of other animals can become an acceptable entry in the management plan.
Aldabra demonstrates that animals can recover when humans stop exploiting them. Its next conservation decisions will test whether that respect extends beyond the species we have chosen to save.


Spay/neutering of your feral cat population can be done. I’m not sure what can be done for your black rats. You don’t have to kill either population. Yes this will take effort. Trap them, spay/neuter and keep in a sanctuary. Living with feral cats is possible; I’ve done it. Rats are also pretty amazing and intelligent animals.
Both these options are possible. So why not begin?