Britain considers forcing tubes down ducks’ and geese’s throats so cruel that producing foie gras has been prohibited here since 2007. But apparently, paying somebody in France to do exactly the same thing is a perfectly acceptable arrangement.
Now, after promising to close that loophole, Labour is preparing to abandon its proposed ban on foie gras imports to secure a food trade agreement with the European Union.
Before the election, Steve Reed, then shadow environment secretary, described force-feeding ducks and geese as “beyond disgusting” and promised to prohibit imports.
The Victims of a Trade Agreement
Foie gras translates to “fat liver”, which is a rather sanitised description of what the industry actually produces.
Ducks and geese are repeatedly restrained while workers insert feeding tubes down their throats, pumping excessive quantities of food directly into their stomachs. This process, known as gavage, typically continues for 12 to 15 days before slaughter. Their livers swell to 7 to 10 times their normal size, deliberately inducing fatty liver disease. The consequences can include injuries to the oesophagus, difficulty breathing, impaired movement and increased mortality.
According to research published by the Animal-Human Policy Center, mortality among force-fed Mulard ducks has been reported at 2% to 6%, compared with approximately 0.2% during normal rearing. These birds are not developing an illness that farmers are struggling to prevent. Making them ill is the entire business model. They are deliberately bred, confined, subjected to invasive feeding and eventually killed because somebody considers their diseased liver a luxury ingredient.
Cruelty Has No Borders
The Guardian reports that Labour’s proposed import ban is expected to be formally abandoned on the 20th of November (the time of writing was the 18th) as part of a sanitary and phytosanitary agreement with the EU.
The agreement aims to reduce paperwork and border checks for food businesses. Ministers claim it could boost the British economy by up to £5 billion annually. France, Europe’s largest foie gras producer, has resisted restrictions on its exports. The proposed agreement creates another obstacle to Britain’s promised import prohibition.
The economic benefits of easier trade may be substantial. That does not change what happens to the birds whose bodies become products within that trade. Nor does the fact that force-feeding happens abroad make it any less cruel.
We raised precisely this contradiction in February 2025, when Labour’s promise first appeared vulnerable to negotiations with the EU. Britain has already determined that this method of production is unacceptable within its own borders. Continuing to permit imports means British businesses can still financially support the very practice domestic legislation prohibits. And other countries have demonstrated that different decisions are possible.
Brazil Banned It. The USA Is Following.
In July, Brazil became the first country to prohibit both foie gras production and sales nationwide. President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva signed the legislation after unanimous congressional approval, despite reported diplomatic pressure from France. Brazil’s domestic foie gras industry was tiny. Prohibiting sales was therefore particularly significant because it addressed the imported products that would otherwise remain available. The contrast with Britain is difficult to ignore.
Meanwhile, voters in two American cities have taken matters into their own hands.
On the 3rd of November, 73% of voters in Washington, D.C. and 66.55% in Denver approved measures prohibiting force-feeding for foie gras and restricting its commercial sale, distribution and importation. Both measures are scheduled to take effect on the 1st of July 2027, although industry representatives have threatened legal challenges. So while British ministers prepare to abandon an import prohibition, voters elsewhere are approving restrictions that go beyond domestic production.
Even Customers Don’t Want It
A 2026 study involving 5,665 respondents across 10 American states and Washington, D.C. found overwhelming support for restrictions on foie gras. Across participants who received different levels of information about its production:
- 89% supported banning force-feeding ducks and geese to produce foie gras.
- 87% supported banning sales of foie gras produced through force-feeding.
- 81% supported banning foie gras sales altogether.
The researchers also tested how foie gras affected restaurant preferences.
When presented with an otherwise identical restaurant menu, 40.1% of respondents indicated they would be likely to visit without foie gras listed. That figure fell to 28.1% when foie gras appeared. These were hypothetical preferences among American respondents, not measured restaurant sales or British polling. Nevertheless, the findings challenge the assumption that restaurants need foie gras to attract customers. The most effective messaging generally focused on what happened to the birds, rather than potential economic or public health consequences. People did not need an elaborate financial argument to recognise the suffering involved.
They needed to understand what was being done.
Foie Gras Is Not the Only Injustice
There is, however, a danger in treating foie gras as an exceptional cruelty rather than one particularly disturbing example of a much wider injustice.
As we previously examined, nearly 4.2 billion ducks were killed for food worldwide in 2023. Foie gras production is estimated to account for only around 1% of ducks killed annually. The others might escape force-feeding, but they are still bred, confined and killed because humans regard their bodies as food. Ending foie gras imports would not resolve that fundamental injustice.
It would stop British businesses purchasing one especially invasive product of animal exploitation, but it would leave the broader assumption that ducks and geese exist for human consumption untouched. That assumption deserves just as much scrutiny as force-feeding itself.
Ducks and geese are individuals with interests in their own lives, not ingredients waiting to acquire a sufficiently impressive French name.
Whether they are force-fed for foie gras or killed for an ordinary dinner, their lives belong to them. Britain has spent nearly two decades prohibiting foie gras production while permitting the same suffering to be purchased from overseas. Labour promised to address that contradiction, but its proposed import ban is now being sacrificed in trade negotiations.
The birds have no interest in which side of the Channel the feeding tube is inserted. And no trade agreement changes their right to live without being exploited.

