The International Whaling Commission has spent 40 years operating under a moratorium on commercial whaling. At its 70th meeting, countries were still arguing over whether whales should be commercially killed at all. IWC70 concluded in Hobart, Australia, on the 2nd of October, marking both the Commission’s 80th anniversary and 4 decades since the commercial whaling moratorium came into force. The moratorium remains in place, but the meeting exposed how far international agreement on whales still has to go.
Most strikingly, a proposal to create a South Atlantic Whale Sanctuary failed again. The sanctuary, proposed by Brazil, Argentina and Uruguay, needed support from 75% of voting countries because it would amend the IWC Schedule. It received 39 votes in favour and 18 against, while Iceland and Türkiye abstained. The same proposal had fallen just one vote short at IWC69 in 2024. So a majority supported the sanctuary. It still was not enough.
There was progress elsewhere. Resolutions covering vessel strikes, cetacean strandings and the trade in fish maw and incidental deaths of threatened cetaceans were adopted, while the Hobart Declaration marking the Commission’s 80th anniversary was adopted by consensus. The UK also announced £150,000 towards a new Global Cetacean Strandings Database.
But another debate hanging over the meeting concerned something supposedly settled 40 years ago.
Commercial Whaling Is Still Being Defended
The IWC agreed in 1982 to pause commercial whaling from the 1985/86 season onwards. That moratorium remains in place today. Norway formally objected to it, while Iceland later rejoined the IWC with a reservation. Japan left the Commission in 2019 and resumed commercial whaling outside its rules.
At IWC70, Antigua and Barbuda had again proposed a resolution concerning the “sustainable use” of whale populations. It was withdrawn on the final day. The country nevertheless attempted to begin a process through the Scientific Committee that could re-examine the commercial whaling moratorium, an effort opposed by New Zealand, the UK and Mexico.
There had also been significant opposition outside the meeting. A coalition delivered a petition containing 5,585 signatures from 87 countries and territories asking Antigua and Barbuda to withdraw the resolution, while visiting yacht captains also appealed to the government to drop it.
Much of the international debate around whaling inevitably focuses on populations, sustainability and conservation. A population judged capable of surviving a certain number of deaths is made up of individual whales. Demonstrating that humans can kill some of them without causing a population collapse does not, by itself, answer why those individuals should be killed for commercial purposes. That distinction becomes particularly difficult to ignore when we look at what is happening in the countries still killing whales.
Iceland Could Be About to Leave Whaling Behind
While Iceland abstained from the South Atlantic sanctuary vote, its own commercial whaling industry could soon face a much bigger change. As we reported in September, Iceland’s government plans to submit legislation in February 2027 that could permanently ban commercial whaling.
By the 8th of September this year, 80 fin whales had reportedly been killed in Icelandic waters from an annual quota of 150. Fin whales are the second-largest animals on Earth and are classified as vulnerable to extinction. A government-commissioned investigation published in 2023 also found that some whales struck with explosive harpoons took as long as 2 hours to die. There is still a complication. Iceland’s remaining whaling company, Hvalur, holds a permit running until 2029, raising the possibility that existing permissions could continue even if the country decides to introduce a ban. But Iceland considering an end to commercial whaling at all leaves Norway increasingly exposed.
Norway Killed 418 Whales This Year
Norway’s 2026 hunt ended with 418 minke whales killed from a government quota of 1,641. Whale and Dolphin Conservation says around 40% of whales killed in Norway are pregnant, meaning the published kill figure does not include the unborn calves who die with them. And this is not an industry being driven by overwhelming domestic demand. WDC reports that only around 1% of Norwegians regularly eat whale flesh. IWC70 showed 2 very different directions still competing internationally: greater protection for whales on one side, and continuing attempts to preserve commercial killing on the other.
Herbivore Club has launched a petition calling on the Norwegian Government to permanently ban commercial whaling, stop issuing commercial quotas and support people currently involved in the industry towards alternative sources of income. Sign & Share the petition calling for Norway to ban commercial whaling.

