More than 2,000 fish died at Furnace Brook in East Sussex in June 2024. Others sank to the bottom and were never counted. Large eels were seen climbing out of the lake before dying on the banks. The pollution incident was severe enough for the Environment Agency to classify it as Category 1. Fifteen trailer-loads of dead fish were removed. The angling business disappeared overnight. Its owners estimate £500,000 in lost income, while a biologist estimated the lake could take 10 to 15 years to recover.
People who visited Furnace Brook had come to recognise individuals and named them. Diane Gould described developing relationships with them “as living beings”. Her son Simon had spent more than 15 years looking after the lake and described the fish as his babies. But this was a fishing lake.
People came there to catch those same individuals before throwing them back.
We are perfectly capable of recognising fishes as individuals when thousands of their bodies suddenly appear on the surface of a poisoned lake. We recognise the horror of them gasping, suffocating and trying to escape the water. We mourn animals we knew individually.
Then, once the water is clean again, the plan is to resume deliberately catching them for recreation. The pollution itself remains under investigation. More than two years after the deaths, the Environment Agency told the Guardian that it was still progressing its investigation and had found no evidence of the illegal importation of waste to neighbouring Morgans Farm.
Pollution laws can punish people for killing fishes indirectly, here is a recent example, but our relationship with fishes becomes much less coherent when killing, injuring or frightening them is the activity we intended all along.
Furnace Brook should recover. Its water should be clean. Polluters should be held accountable. But restoring a fishing lake should not mean restoring everything exactly as it was.
If those fish were individuals when they floated dead on the surface, they were individuals when they were alive beneath it too.

