Tell people you’re pregnant and eating entirely plant-based and suddenly everyone becomes deeply concerned about protein, iron, calcium, B12 and whether your baby will grow properly.
But where is that scrutiny when somebody eats animals?
A study published in the International Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics adds to the evidence that eating plant-based during pregnancy does not automatically mean poorer outcomes.
Researchers at the Coombe Hospital in Dublin examined pregnancies between 2022 and 2024, comparing 68 women eating entirely plant-based with 10,270 women eating other diets. The results?
Median birth weight was 3,390g among the plant-based group and 3,410g among those eating other diets.
Premature delivery before 37 weeks occurred in 7.4% of the plant-based group compared with 9.5% of the other-diet group.
Gestational diabetes occurred in 8.8% of the plant-based group compared with 9.9% among those eating other diets.
Gestational hypertension was recorded in 0% of the plant-based group compared with 3.5% of the other-diet group.
None of these differences was statistically significant.
Even anaemia was remarkably similar: 17.6% among women eating plant-based compared with 16.1% among women eating other diets.
The researchers concluded that pregnancy outcomes were equivalent between the two groups in their cohort.
There is an important limitation. Only 68 women were in the plant-based group, so this study cannot settle every question about plant-based pregnancy. The researchers themselves call for larger, longer-term studies.
But this study doesn’t exist in a vacuum.
The experts aren’t telling pregnant women they need animals
The NHS says people eating entirely plant-based can get the nutrients they need and specifically provides guidance for pregnancy and breastfeeding.
The British Nutrition Foundation says that with careful meal planning and a varied, balanced intake, mothers-to-be eating plant-based should be able to obtain the nutrients both they and their babies need.
The Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics explicitly identifies the idea that these eating patterns are inappropriate during pregnancy as a myth, saying a well-planned vegetarian or entirely plant-based eating pattern can meet nutritional requirements during pregnancy and lactation.
Dietitians Australia provides specific guidance for pregnant women eating plant-based, recommending B12 supplementation and attention to protein, iron, iodine and omega-3. It recommends planning with a dietitian, not adding animal products.
The Mayo Clinic says that, with planning, plant-based eating patterns can meet the needs of people who are pregnant or breastfeeding.
And the Heart & Stroke Foundation of Canada says vegetarian and entirely plant-based eating patterns can provide all the nutrients needed at any age.
This isn’t fringe nutrition advice. It is mainstream.
But what about “well planned”?
This phrase gets treated as though it is an admission of weakness. It isn’t.
Every pregnancy needs nutritional planning. Eating animals does not magically tick every nutritional box. Assuming that because you eat meat, eggs or dairy you must therefore be getting enough iron, iodine, folate, vitamin D or every other nutrient is a pretty good to get deficiencies.
The Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics advises all pregnant women to eat a variety of nutrient-rich foods and notes that vitamin or mineral supplementation may be necessary. Dietitians Australia likewise says pregnancy increases nutrient requirements and that supplements may sometimes be needed. So why is nutritional planning presented as suspicious when someone eats plant-based, but simply called prenatal nutrition when everyone else does it? Of course people eating entirely plant-based need reliable B12. Iron, iodine, calcium, vitamin D, omega-3 and protein deserve attention too. The study itself discusses these nutrients.
That isn’t evidence that humans need to eat animals. It is evidence that pregnant humans need nutrients.
And animals are not nutrients.

