Three women walked into a field on the Sandringham Estate and took 3 lambs.
They did not hide what they had done.
The following day, Rose Patterson, Sarah Foy and Rosa Sharkey stood outside Windsor Castle holding signs saying “I rescued the King’s sheep”, then reported themselves to police.
More than 3 years later, a jury at Norwich Crown Court found all three guilty of theft. But were Sammy, Sunny and Sooty stolen, or were they rescued?
Legally, the verdict is clear. The women removed animals who were considered somebody else’s property without permission. Each received a 12-month community order, 150 hours of unpaid work and was ordered to contribute £250 towards prosecution costs. But calling someone property does not tell us whether taking them away was wrong.
The 3 lambs were being farmed for food. Animal Rising says they would have been slaughtered had they remained there. Instead, Sammy, Sunny and Sooty are now fully grown and living at a sanctuary.
Nobody disputes that Patterson, Foy and Sharkey took them. The disagreement is over what that act means. Animal Rising calls this tactic an “open rescue”. Those carrying it out do not conceal their identities and hand themselves over to police once the animals have been taken somewhere safe. The group says part of the purpose is to establish legal precedents around removing animals from farms, laboratories and breeding facilities.
That makes this very different from somebody stealing a television. The television does not have an interest in what happens next. Sammy, Sunny and Sooty did.
During the trial, Sharkey said the activists had seen one sheep with a severe limp and found an empty water trough on a hot day. She told the court that taking the lambs was the “only way we could ensure any sheep were saved”.
The activists spent hours in the field getting the lambs accustomed to their presence before removing them, according to a later report on the case.
The entire case depends upon a legal arrangement in which one animal can belong to another. Once that is accepted, everything else follows quite neatly. The lambs were property. The activists had no permission. The property was removed. Theft. But the moral question begins one step earlier.
Why were Sammy, Sunny and Sooty property in the first place?
Patterson said after the verdict that the 3 were rescued because “they deserved the chance of a long life, rather than having their lives cut short simply because they were being farmed for food”. That is the part the language of ownership struggles to accommodate.
If somebody removes a dog from circumstances in which they believe the dog is in danger, most people can at least understand why the word “rescue” might be used. Farmed animals occupy a different legal and cultural category. Their anticipated killing is not necessarily evidence that something has gone wrong. Killing them is often the intended outcome. So saving them from that outcome can itself become the offence.
Patterson also told the court that she wanted “to save lambs that day and raise some awareness for the lambs we couldn’t save”. Those two aims are inseparable. Sammy, Sunny and Sooty are not symbols invented for a campaign. They are 3 sheep who were going somewhere before Patterson, Foy and Sharkey intervened. They are somewhere else now. They grew up.
More than 10 million sheep are slaughtered in the UK each year. 3 surviving does almost nothing to change that number. But that is not an argument against rescuing 3. We would never tell someone not to save 3 dogs because millions of other animals remained in danger.
The King became central to the activists’ defence because they argued that his reputation as an environmentalist and animal lover meant he might have approved of what they had done. Sharkey said they hoped the rescue might prompt him to reconsider farming practices on his estate. Whether King Charles agrees is unknown.
It is also beside the larger point.
The lives of Sammy, Sunny and Sooty should not depend upon whether the person legally entitled to have them killed happens to be persuaded to spare them. The jury decided Patterson, Foy and Sharkey committed theft. Sammy, Sunny and Sooty remain at the sanctuary. They do not know that they were once somebody’s property. They do not know that 12 jurors unanimously decided their removal met the legal definition of theft. They know the life that came afterwards. And that life is only possible because 3 people looked at animals who legally belonged to somebody else and decided that liberation was the only option.

