Most people say the same thing when choosing food for their dog.
Health comes first.
In a survey of 2,596 dog guardians, 94.5% said health and nutrition were important when choosing food, ahead of quality, palatability, naturalness and price.84% were feeding either conventional or raw meat-based food. Just 12.8% were feeding a plant-based diet. But if our concern is what dogs need, why are we so attached to meat?
Dogs do not need cows. They do not need chickens. They do not need pigs.
They need nutrients. And increasingly, the evidence suggests those nutrients do not have to come from another animal’s body.
The science has moved on
A 2026 review of 31 studies examined the digestibility of plant-based and vegetarian diets and ingredients for dogs and cats. Across different study designs, ingredients and methods, digestibility was consistently high and broadly comparable with conventional meat-based food. Among studies looking specifically at complete diets, all 7 concluded that the plant-based or vegetarian diets were well digested.
That does not mean you can throw some lentils in a bowl and call it dog food.
Protein digestibility is not the same thing as complete nutrition, and researchers have called for more work on micronutrients, older animals, puppies, unwell dogs and real-world feeding.
But that is an argument for properly formulated food. It is not an argument for slaughter. The same review notes that by early 2026, most research examining health outcomes in dogs fed well-formulated plant-based diets supported their use.
So why does meat remain the default?
Loving one animal, eating another
We have built an entire culture around treating dogs as family while treating cows, chickens, pigs and fishes as ingredients.
The researchers behind the dog food acceptance study call this the “animal lover’s paradox”: caring deeply about one group of animals while purchasing food produced through the killing of others. And the usual defence that dog food merely uses slaughterhouse “waste” does not make the contradiction disappear. The same paper notes that almost half of animal-derived ingredients used in US dog food were suitable for human consumption, while slaughter by-products have economic value and support animal agriculture rather than simply making unwanted waste vanish. Calling part of someone’s body a “by-product” does not make their death irrelevant.
It just changes the accounting.
The environmental cost is enormous too
Even if we ignored the animals being killed, meat-based dog food carries another cost. A UK study of 31 commercially available dry dog foods found plant-based foods had the lowest environmental impact across every measure assessed, including land use, greenhouse gas emissions, acidification, eutrophication and freshwater withdrawal. Per 1,000 kcal, beef-based food required an estimated 102.15 m² of land, compared with 2.73 m² for plant-based food. Greenhouse gas emissions were 31.47 kg CO₂e for beef-based food, compared with 2.82 kg for plant-based.
The broader environmental review is even harder to dismiss. It found ingredient choice was the biggest driver of companion animal food’s environmental impact, with animal-derived ingredients responsible for much of the burden.
So we are killing animals to feed dogs while using dramatically more land, producing more emissions and placing more pressure on ecosystems to do it.
For what?
Guardians are interested, but habit still wins
The survey does offer some hope.
Among guardians feeding conventional or raw meat-based diets, more than 43% said they would consider at least one more sustainable alternative if their requirements were met. Cultivated meat was the most popular, followed by vegetarian, insect-based and plant-based food. But 56.8% rejected every alternative offered. That is striking when the same respondents overwhelmingly claimed health and nutrition were their priorities. The survey was not globally representative. Most respondents were women, most were from the UK, and people with higher education and vegans were overrepresented.
Still, the contradiction it exposes is familiar. We say dogs are family. We say animals deserve compassion. We say climate change matters. Then we open a tin containing the body of another animal because that is what we have always done.
There is nothing wrong with putting a dog’s health first. We should. But protecting one animal does not require pretending everyone else is expendable.
A nutritionally complete plant-based food asks a much better question than whether we can make animal exploitation slightly more sustainable.
It asks why another animal should have to die for dinner at all.

