A barramundi caught in a fishing net is a successful catch. A threatened animal caught in the same net is an environmental problem. The difference is simply whether the fishing industry intended to catch them. That distinction is driving a dispute over plans to ban gillnets in Australia’s Great Barrier Reef fishing zone.
The nets trap fish by their gills, but their victims extend beyond the species being targeted. According to the Australian Marine Conservation Society (AMCS), the remaining gillnet fishery catches thousands of threatened animals every year. Queensland and Australia’s federal government agreed in 2023 to phase out the nets by 30 June 2027. Now, ABC News reports, commercial fishers are demanding another 3 years.
Senator Susan McDonald supports their campaign, arguing that an extension would allow fishers to demonstrate that gillnet fishing is “incredibly targeted”. Thousands of threatened animals caught annually might suggest otherwise. But even a perfectly selective net would present a rather obvious problem for the barramundi.
These fish aren’t unfortunate casualties of fishing. They’re the intended victims. They’re deliberately caught, removed from their environment and killed to satisfy demand for their flesh. Their deaths are precisely what makes the enterprise profitable. But the controversy centres on the economic consequences of preventing those deaths from happening in quite the same way.
In Ayr, seafood shop operators Heather and Peter Bradford warn that losing gillnet fishing could wipe out 80% of their business. Fisher Neil Green fears being forced into retirement. Fishers have already received financial assistance, while temporary licences have permitted continued fishing under camera monitoring. 3 years of trials involving alternative equipment have failed to deliver a replacement.
The industry wants more time to continue catching fish using nets that also endanger other animals. Conservationists oppose extending the deadline, but the AMCS supports finding alternative methods, including ways to catch fish without the same impact on threatened species. That would be a meaningful improvement for animals spared the nets. It would do nothing for the barramundi deliberately caught instead.
The same fundamental assumption survives every proposed solution: fish are entitled to protection when their capture is unintended or their species is threatened, but their individual lives count for remarkably little when someone wants to sell them. A threatened animal doesn’t suffer because a fisher caught the wrong species. Nor does a barramundi have less interest in living because the fisher got the species right.
Ending gillnet fishing could protect thousands of animals from capture. Replacing the nets with hooks or traps would still leave fish dying to supply the same businesses. A fishing method isn’t ethically justified simply because it becomes more accurate at selecting its victims.


This all makes me so sick, but I worry that sadly that the people who read this are already on your side. All the other people that mindlessly consume fish have no thoughts about where they come from or the sacrifices made. People aren't cruel intentionally, they are just extremely ignorant. It's so exasperating. Every animal wants to live and has the right to have its life. The thought of fish being trapped by their gills makes me want to weep. I hope your article can be sent out to reach a very wide audience. Pictures of this pitiful situation would also speak a thousand words. Thank you for this post and for helping the animals.