Fish populations in New South Wales, Australia, have become so depleted that the state government is proposing restrictions on how many can be caught. Yellowtail kingfish populations are particularly concerning, with the agriculture minister describing them as “dangerously low”.
The proposals would reduce annual kingfish catches from 250 tonnes to 120 tonnes, alongside new restrictions on snapper fishing. The intention is to allow populations to recover while continuing to permit commercial and recreational fishing. Unsurprisingly, people who make money from catching and selling fish are unhappy. Businesses warn of rising prices, falling profits and customers abandoning fishing trips when they can no longer take home as many dead animals. But among the objections is one that exposes something considerably more disturbing than the industry’s concern for its profits.
Commercial fisherman Noel Gogerly warned that snapper caught beyond the proposed limits would have to be returned to the ocean, where many would die anyway. Fish pulled from deep water can suffer internal damage from the sudden change in pressure. Returning them to the ocean does not necessarily save their lives. They may simply float on the surface until they die or are eaten by sharks. Gogerly described this prospect as “a good product that’s going to go to waste.”
A snapper has been dragged from the depths, suffered potentially fatal injuries and lost any chance of continuing their life. But the tragedy, apparently, is that somebody might not get to sell their body. The implication is extraordinary. A fish who dies and becomes someone’s dinner has fulfilled a purpose. A fish who dies and feeds a shark has been wasted.
Except the fish has lost exactly the same thing in either scenario.
There is, however, a legitimate criticism buried beneath this commercial understanding of death. If restrictions only limit how many fish can be kept, rather than how many can be caught, animals may continue to die without those deaths contributing to the permitted catch. Conservation measures that are supposed to protect fish populations could consequently deliver less protection than intended. But allowing fishers to retain those bodies would merely make the deaths commercially useful. It would do nothing for the individuals who died.
The obvious alternative is to prevent those fish from being caught in the first place. Instead, much of the opposition revolves around preserving the benefits humans derive from catching them.
Charter operator Craig McGill complained that restricting recreational fishers to one kingfish per boat, rather than five per person, could destroy his business. Four paying customers might have to share a single fish. Apparently, the opportunity to spend time on the ocean becomes considerably less attractive when everybody cannot take home someone they have killed.
Meanwhile, fisheries management director Heath Folpp explained that the government wanted to distribute restrictions fairly between commercial and recreational fishers, ensuring both experienced approximately the same economic pain. The interests of the fish themselves are conspicuously absent from this calculation. Even the government’s conservation proposals ultimately treat their continued existence as a means of sustaining future fishing. Populations must recover so that humans can continue removing individuals from them.
Reducing catches may spare lives and help depleted populations recover. Those are worthwhile outcomes. But conservation remains fundamentally different from recognising that individual fish have an interest in remaining alive, regardless of how many others of their species exist. And the industry’s own objections demonstrate precisely why that distinction is necessary.
If fish are dying because people insist upon catching them, deciding who gets to keep their bodies is not the solution.
The solution is to stop catching them.

